Freedom of Speech should be color blind

A lot of people have been calling for Don Imus' head over the last couple of days. His remarks about the Rutgers Women's Basketball team have been fodder for the usual suspects in the black community. Jesse Jackson has been saying it's either him or us, like anyone actually listens to him any more. Al Sharpton says that Imus might be a good guy, but that he should be made an example of to keep others in line. And by others, he definitely only means other white people.  UPDATE - Since I started writing this entry, Imus has been canned by CBS.  I guess their idea is the he is free to say whatever he wants, but now he has to say it some place else.  It will be interesting to see where his career goes, if anywhere.

Disclaimer: I am a 36 year old white male. I grew up in a suburb of Washington, DC and have been around people of different races and religions all my life. In fact, I was a minority in my high school and was never really bothered by it. I do not listen to Imus in the Morning or any of the other immature shock jocks on the radio. I do not believe there is any so sacred that it can be poked fun at or made fun of.

In today's America, Freedom of Speech isn't equal across color lines. Things that a black comic will say every night on stage will get a white comic crucified. If the N-word is such a bad word, how come it's so freaking funny when Chris Rock uses it in his act or when Carlos Mencia tries to get it on a license plate? How the heck did In Living Color ever get on television with some of the things said in its skits? Why is it that black people only get offended when the words are said why white people? Why is it that gay people only freak out when it's a straight person making the comments? Since when did basic freedoms start applying differently depending on your skin color, religion, or sexual preference? Of course, being a white male, there are no slurs that I can consider patently offensive, no matter who says them. Well, maybe liberal!

Well, the answer to that last question is always. Skin color in America has always been an issue, but not in this way. The minorities of this country have good reason to resent the way they have been treated in the past, but I believe that at some point you have to move beyond what happened in the past or be forced to have your point of view ignored. Think about it this way, if you have a friend who gets offended at every other thing you say, are you going to want to hang out with that person or even going to worry about what they think.  The comments coming our of Rutgers talk about pain and healing. Tell the truth....have you ever truly been injured by the words of a stranger? If your answer is yes, maybe you you should look deep inside and ask yourself why.

A better tact might have been to print up t-shirts like this and sell them to all of the Rutgers students and fans. It's definitely better than what Nike has done.  The time has come in this country to stop treating races with any more or less respect than they treat themselves. If black men want to refer to themselves with the N word, they have no right to get offended when anyone else refers to them in that manner.

Finally, in the light of the tragedy at Virginia Tech yesterday, does it put into perspective how silly it is to get offended by what someone says? 

<< Previous Document / Next Document >>
  • 1) Changes Are In the Making - H. Lewis Smith
    Created 4/18/2007 12:53:31 AM email | website

    Most of white America isn't aware of an anti-n-word movement presently building throughout the black community which is being directed primarily at black users of the word and other demeaning terms. Insofar, as Imus is concerned, everything is about timing and his was all wrong...of course this goes without saying that he had no business saying what he said in the first place...but he did get caught up in something that's brewing within the black community. To learn more please go to:

    { Link }

  • 2) crux - Kitty Elsmore
    Created 4/18/2007 8:31:40 AM email | website

    "The time has come in this country to stop treating races with any more or less respect than they treat themselves. If black men want to refer to themselves with the N word, they have no right to get offended when anyone else refers to them in that manner."

    This for me is the crux of the matter and I couldn't have put it better myself.

    It is interesting, but I must admit not surprising, to learn of the growing movement in the black community highlighted above. Let us hope it continues and spawns similar movements in like situations elswhere.

  • 3) I agree... sorta - Charles Robinson
    Created 4/18/2007 9:49:51 AM email | website

    Sean, I'm a little confused by what your real message is. Are you saying it's acceptable for minorities to decry hate rhetoric as long as they don't use it themselves (which I agree is hypocritical), or are you saying it's a character flaw to find hate speech hurtful?

    You and most of the people who read your blog are able to discern that the people voicing the hateful rhetoric are simpletons to be pitied. Unfortunately the majority of the lemming public aren't so enlightened. I don't find Chris Rock, Carlos Mencia, or Dave Chappelle's use of racist remarks to be the least bit funny. There are some things each of them say that counts as humor, but the deliberate use of racism because they feel they're part of the minority in question is hypocritical and just plain wrong.

    I do agree with your parting comment: people who use discriminatory language to refer to themselves or other members of their minority have no right to get offended when anyone else refers to them in that manner.

    Finally, as a member of a minority that isn't legally recognized but is still heavily discriminated against (with special legislation to infringe my rights) I'm concerned whenever I see hate speech go unchallenged. I've been in situations where I truly felt that I could have been seriously harmed for simply being gay, and it always starts with language that dehumanizes the target and lowers the barrier to escalating the words to actions.

    As a society we need to send a strong message that all people are equal and not tolerate discriminatory language from any source.

  • 4) My Point - Sean Burgess
    Created 4/18/2007 11:49:59 PM email | website

    @Charles

    My point in this entry is very simple: Standards for speech have to be the same for everyone. It can't be OK for one group to use certain words and phrases if that same language won't be tolerated coming from a second group. I honestly don't care what the rules are as long as everyone has to play by them.

    @Lewis

    I truly hope that the change of which you speak occurs, but I have my doubts. There is a very serious attitude change that needs to occur within the black community and I am not sure if, when, or how it might come about. Until that happens, I don't see any comedian relenting in their portrayal of the ignorance of the black community any more than white comics steer clear of Redneck jokes. And I think it's slightly wrong to blame comedians for their act when all they are truly doing is putting up a mirror and letting their audience see how stupid humanity can be. If it is shocking, maybe it will make the target of their jokes take notice and try to make some changes for the better.

  • 5) Can Schedule Orders (and Schedule BPAs) Be Set-Aside for Small Business? - saƧ ekimi
    Created 5/11/2010 5:36:10 AM email |

    Hi;

    Unfortunately, although I realize I could not read the topic defalrca to help me in this regard would be glad if the mail.

    mary lou

    marylou23@gmail.com

    { Link }

Post A Comment
Subject: (required)
Name: (required)
Email: (required)
Web Site:
Comment:(No HTML - Links will be converted if prefixed http://)

Remember Me?